FEINGOLD,
HAGEL EFFORT TO STRENGTHEN INTELLIGENCE GATHERING PASSES COMMITTEE
Bipartisan Effort Builds on the Work of the 9/11 Commission, is
Endorsed by Prominent Intelligence and Foreign Policy Experts
May 1, 2008
Washington, D.C. –
U.S. Senators Russ Feingold (D-WI) and Chuck Hagel (R-NE), both members
of the Senate Intelligence and Foreign Relations Committees, announced
today that new legislation they authored was included in the Intelligence
Authorization bill approved by the Intelligence Committee Thursday.
Their bipartisan effort builds on the work of the 9/11 Commission by
strengthening our intelligence and information gathering around the
world, especially in places where the U.S. doesn’t have enough
of a presence on the ground today. The 9/11 Commission warned that we
must focus “toward remote regions and failing states,” but
three and a half years later the U.S. has not yet responded to these
warnings. The U.S. government and intelligence community tends to focus
on current threats at the expense of having the “strategic depth”
to analyze and anticipate potential threats and surprises lurking over
the horizon. The focus on current reporting has been cited, including
by the Director of National Intelligence, as a problem in the Intelligence
Community’s ability to forecast significant events.
The Feingold-Hagel legislation
establishes an independent commission to improve how the U.S. government
collects and analyzes information, so that we can head off emerging
threats. The Commission would look not just at strengthening formal
intelligence gathering, but at getting more information from U.S. diplomats
and other U.S. officials stationed around the world. It would also look
into ways to enhance the language skills and cultural understanding
of intelligence officers and diplomats.
“Over the last six
years, we have not done nearly enough to fix the gaps in our intelligence
gathering that contributed to the 9/11 attacks,” Feingold said.
“We should be ahead of the curve, anticipating emerging threats,
but our intelligence officials have acknowledged that we still don’t
have intelligence gathering capabilities we need. We need a strategic
approach to collecting more information, from more sources, and a better
strategy for how to analyze that information so we can address crises
before they happen.”
Senator Hagel said, “This
bi-partisan Commission would enhance Congress’ oversight of intelligence
and foreign information gathering. Strategic depth in collection and
analysis is an issue that cuts across the oversight responsibilities
of both the Intelligence and the Foreign Relations Committees. The Commission
would examine diplomatic as well as intelligence reporting, and would
help provide an in-depth analysis of these issues, to ensure the United
States government receives the information and analysis it needs to
anticipate future strategic challenges.”
The Feingold-Hagel initiative
is supported by:
- Zbigniew Brzezinski
– Former National Security Advisor to President Carter; Professor
of American Foreign Policy - School of Advanced International Studies,
Johns Hopkins University.
- Donald Gregg
– National Security Advisor to Vice-President George H.W. Bush
1982-1988; CIA 1951-1982; Chairman of the Board, The Korea Society.
- Larry Wilkerson
–Former Chief of Staff to Secretary of State Colin Powell; Professor
of Government and Public Policy at the College of William and Mary;
U.S. Army (Ret.).
- Carl Ford
- Assistant Secretary of State for Intelligence and Research 2001-03;
Former intelligence officer in the Army, the Defense Intelligence
Agency, and the CIA.
- Gayle Smith
- Former Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for
African Affairs at the National Security Council; Senior Fellow, Center
for American Progress.
- David Kay
– Former Head of the Iraq Survey Group; Senior Fellow, Potomac
Institute for Policy Studies concentrating in counterterrorism and
weapons proliferation
- Rand Beers
- Former Senior Director and Special Assistant to the President for
Intelligence Programs; President, National Security Network.
Fact
Sheet: Feingold-Hagel Initiative to Fill Intelligence Gaps
“I always worry about
the next threat... We tend to focus intently on the current threat,
and I’d like to keep some group with wary eyes looking over the
horizon at what might be next.” – Director of National Intelligence
Mike McConnell.
Why is the legislation
needed?
The United States government lacks capabilities for collecting
intelligence and information around the world. By its own admission,
the Intelligence Community lacks “global reach,” which is
necessary to collect information in terrorist safe havens and other
far-flung areas where we have national security interests, and devotes
a “disproportionate” level of resources toward current crises,
rather than to long-term strategic challenges and emerging threats.
These are challenges not just for the Intelligence Community, but for
diplomats and other U.S. government officials who serve as America’s
eyes and ears. We need an effective interagency process that addresses
our intelligence and information gaps, identifies both the clandestine
and non-clandestine resources needed to fill those gaps, and allocates
resources accordingly.
What the legislation
does:
The bill would establish an independent, nonpartisan Foreign
Intelligence and Information Commission to:
- Evaluate the U.S. government’s
global strategies to collect foreign intelligence and information;
- Evaluate the extent to
which the government coordinates collection and analysis strategies
across agencies and among clandestine, diplomatic, military, and open
source channels;
- Evaluate whether human
and budgetary resources are directed across agencies to meet strategic
foreign intelligence and information collection strategies;
- Evaluate the government’s
efforts to promote language, cultural training, and other qualifications
for personnel serving abroad to more effectively collect foreign intelligence
and information; and
- Make recommendations to
the executive branch and Congress to address these challenges.
The Commission
The 14-member Foreign Intelligence and Information Commission
would consist of three members appointed by the Senate Majority Leader,
three members appointed by the Senate Minority Leader, three members
appointed by the Speaker of the House, three members appointed by the
House Minority Leader, one non-voting member appointed by the Director
of National Intelligence, and one non-voting member appointed by the
Secretary of State. All members would be private citizens with intelligence,
foreign policy and national security expertise. No later than 18 months
after its formation, the Commission would submit an interim report to
the congressional intelligence committees with findings and recommendations.
No later than six months after the submission of the initial report,
the Commission would submit a final report to the President, Director
of National Intelligence, Secretary of State, and congressional intelligence
committees.
|